I hate most pizza chains, with their over-cheesed but essentially bland pizzas and mediocre toppings. While this is not the best pizza place I've ever been to (you have to go to Vancouver for those), it's better than the horrible "Little Caesars", "Pizza Hut" and even "Panago's" (the latter being the best of the chains). If you are looking for value, order their 3 pizza party pack. Otherwise, for superior pizza, ignore their ordinary pizzas in favour of their extra-topping ones. They're quite good. The place could use a good clean (sticky seats and tables on occasion and the floor can be quite grimy). The self-serve, so called "homemade" soup in crockpots on the counter, is insipid and disgusting. It's like they threw a bunch of leftovers and boiled them in water and called it soup.
Go for the pizza, though!
I've eaten at the peperoni cafe since they closed their sister company Micheal's down the street on 72nd. Which was better
I found the pizza to be better than most the chains because they do use the real mozzarella not that pellet cheese dairy product in the bucket and I do Like the peperoni.
But it's very expensive unless your getting the specials which have little in the topping department
The restaurant it's self is very small no good for kids party's unless they have a hidden room somewhere.
Once in the restaurant I had to witness the owner balling out an employee. Another time the last time while at my brothers place we phoned for delivery and my brother phoned and asked if they could cook the pizza a little longer because it was soggy last time and the owner showed up at his door with the pizza and told him he no longer wanted him as a customer because he was to hard to please.
Needless to say he lost more than one customer that day.