Mrs. C and I were inspired by the previous esteemed reviewer and decided to give this place a try along with a couple of friends. The restaurant was nice enough but the tables were jammed together and it was a little too crowded for my taste. Despite the congestion everything was clean including the w/c.
Service was a bit slow, but our server tried valiantly to keep up with the traffic, much to her credit. I was surprised when I advised another server that we were ready to order and he rudely declared it was not his table and then scampered away.
As for the food, I had the Bolognese with meatballs, and my beloved had the Sicilian, also with meatballs. Our guests had Alfredo and di Frinzi. All were okay but nothing spectacular. Oddly, some of my pasta was al dente and some was mushy. The bread was quite nice, as was the house red wine that we had, although the wine was rather pricey. The only real downside was that there was an insect in Mrs. C's cola, but the server comped us and seemed genuinely distressed. Of course so was Mrs. C, since she had finished half the beverage...
As for value, half price pasta was a good deal, but the meatballs were full price, as was everything else. I think the regular prices are a little steep for what you get, but on cheap Tuesdays it works out okay.
Not sure if I would return.