Wow. When I read a previous review I was excited and planned for twelve friends to go to this new spot. It was a big disappointment. So disappointing that I am writing a negative review for the first time, ever. I won't go so far as rating below 2 though, because I think it has great potential.
The first bad sign was the fact that the TV over the bar was on during the dinner seating, and that they were playing The Wedding Crashers. When it ended they played the DVD menu screen for about an hour, before the replayed the movie. Lame. The space is so nice that I was surprised they would cheapen it like that.
The music was all over the place. Music should really be curated to fit the impression a restaurant is going for. The music did not match the nice space and stylish branding.
When one person ordered a classic gin martini it came without olives. Odd.
The food was, well, not good. Cheap. The pizza was thick and doughy. The Margarita pizza had one piece of basil on it even though that was listed as one of the main ingredients. The ceviche was very over done. Too bad we ordered three orders of it. No one was very thrilled with their food.
The place felt like it was run by teenagers.
A few good things: The server was great, the space is excellent, pretty good bathrooms (but not maintained through the evening). Lots of potential. But they shouldn't play the TV unless there is a good reason — it brings the level of the place down. Maybe that's what they are going for, and I had overly high expectations.
For a place just off Main it should have been packed, and could be if they raised the level of food and paid a little attention to some ambiance details.